Thinking
THE BLACKBIRD
Offline
Forum Master
THE BLACKBIRD
- Posts: 6398
- Thanks: 10935
Thinking
18 Nov 2026 21:38
Thinking of a new project, what is best for a 110mm edf carbon or alloy ?
Thanks: Klipkopwildlife
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Eric
Offline
Moderator
Eric
- Posts: 13776
- Thanks: 14583
Re: Thinking
18 Nov 2026 22:36 - 18 Nov 2026 22:38
That was a rather vague question! I presume you mean for the wing joiner?
110 mm? That's not very big - which part do you mean?
If you meant for the fan housing, carbon is lighter, and weight is critical with edf's.
110 mm? That's not very big - which part do you mean?
If you meant for the fan housing, carbon is lighter, and weight is critical with edf's.
if you are calm and collected when all about you are going berserk - you've missed something important!
Last edit: 18 Nov 2026 22:38 by Eric. Reason: added a comment
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
THE BLACKBIRD
Offline
Forum Master
THE BLACKBIRD
- Posts: 6398
- Thanks: 10935
Re: Thinking
20 Nov 2026 17:28
It was for EDF Eric now another question im looking at a project that has two 76mm Lander fans in the original model i dont know how old it was and lander fans are alloy, i had two 120mm ones in the SR71
Im thinking of fitting two 70mm carbon ones in it, and would think new fans are more efficient than the lander, or it might be possible to get 80mm ones in
Opinions please
Im thinking of fitting two 70mm carbon ones in it, and would think new fans are more efficient than the lander, or it might be possible to get 80mm ones in
Opinions please
Thanks: Eric, Klipkopwildlife
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Eric
Offline
Moderator
Eric
- Posts: 13776
- Thanks: 14583
Re: Thinking
Yesterday 07:00
Simon is really the person to offer for guidance on ducted fans. All I can say is that they are power hungry, noisy, and the duct inlet and outlet shapes and dimensions are critical.
I've only ever flown two d/f models, one was a glider with fan in a pod on the roof. It was ok, but it glided like it was towing a parachute when the motor was off, and the other is the micro Hawk, which with it's micro battery, has power for about two minutes, isn't particularly fast, and is more of a novelty than a serious model. (a bit like the SG in another discussion)
I've only ever flown two d/f models, one was a glider with fan in a pod on the roof. It was ok, but it glided like it was towing a parachute when the motor was off, and the other is the micro Hawk, which with it's micro battery, has power for about two minutes, isn't particularly fast, and is more of a novelty than a serious model. (a bit like the SG in another discussion)
if you are calm and collected when all about you are going berserk - you've missed something important!
Thanks: Klipkopwildlife
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
THE BLACKBIRD
Offline
Forum Master
THE BLACKBIRD
- Posts: 6398
- Thanks: 10935
Re: Thinking
Yesterday 09:04
Iv bit the bullet and ordered two 70mm FMS fans as from what i read they are as good as any and better than most, apart from schulaler at stupid money
The original was 14 years ago and ran both the lander 70mm EDFs on a single 6s 6000 battery and is said to have flown very well, so another Bucc build coming
The original was 14 years ago and ran both the lander 70mm EDFs on a single 6s 6000 battery and is said to have flown very well, so another Bucc build coming
Thanks: Klipkopwildlife
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
S
SimonC
Offline
Premium Member
SimonC
- Posts: 112
- Thanks: 364
Re: Thinking
Yesterday 17:22 - Yesterday 17:24
Alloy fans are now rather out of favour. There are some safety aspects as if an alloy fan should fail the bits are likely to be sharp with no guarantee they will be contained!
Carbon fans are in effect injection moulded so can have a more complex blade profile giving more thrust but with a even higher amp draw! Just make sure the ESC and battery are within the recommended limits. Don't stand close to any EDF running at full power!
Carbon fans are in effect injection moulded so can have a more complex blade profile giving more thrust but with a even higher amp draw! Just make sure the ESC and battery are within the recommended limits. Don't stand close to any EDF running at full power!
Last edit: Yesterday 17:24 by SimonC.
Thanks: Eric, Flytilbroke, THE BLACKBIRD, jon.in.swansea
Please Log in or Create an account to join the conversation.
Time to create page: 0.596 seconds